In North Carolina divorces, the way property and debt are classified has a direct impact on how they are divided. When the marital estate contains distressed real estate—properties worth less than the mortgage owed—dividing that asset becomes more complicated. In Asheville, deeds-in-lieu of foreclosure and short sales are two common ways couples address underwater properties. Both transactions can resolve ownership and debt obligations, but they also raise important questions for equitable distribution: is the distressed property an asset, a debt, or both?
An Asheville divorce lawyer must navigate the intersection of property law, debt classification, and equitable distribution rules to determine how these transactions should be treated. Whether the home is a marital residence, investment property, or vacation home, the classification affects who bears the loss, who receives any remaining value, and whether deficiency balances after the sale become shared marital obligations.
Understanding Distressed Real Estate in Divorce
Distressed real estate is property encumbered by debt exceeding its fair market value. In the context of divorce, the problem is compounded by the need to allocate both the property interest and the underlying liability between the spouses. If neither spouse wants to keep the property or can afford the mortgage, selling it becomes the practical choice.
When the market value is too low to satisfy the mortgage in a standard sale, couples often turn to:
- Deed-in-lieu of foreclosure: Transferring the property back to the lender in exchange for the release of the mortgage obligation.
- Short sale: Selling the property for less than the mortgage balance with lender approval, often involving negotiation of any remaining deficiency.
Both options can resolve ownership but may not completely eliminate liability for the unpaid loan balance. The treatment of that remaining liability in equitable distribution is where the asset-versus-debt question arises.
The Legal Framework for Classifying Assets and Debts
In equitable distribution, North Carolina courts classify property and obligations as marital, separate, or divisible before dividing them.
- Marital property: Assets acquired during the marriage and before the date of separation, owned by one or both spouses, and used for the benefit of the marriage.
- Marital debt: Obligations incurred during the marriage and before the date of separation for the joint benefit of both spouses.
- Separate property and debt: Assets or obligations belonging solely to one spouse, typically acquired before marriage or after separation, or tied solely to one spouse’s benefit.
- Divisible property or debt: Certain assets or liabilities arising after separation but tied to the marital estate.
Distressed real estate often falls into more than one category. The property itself may be a marital asset, but its negative equity may function as a marital debt.
When a Distressed Property Is an Asset
Even if the mortgage exceeds the market value, the property is still technically an asset because it can be sold, transferred, or otherwise disposed of. If the parties are able to negotiate a deed-in-lieu or short sale that fully satisfies the mortgage, the property’s classification as an asset may be straightforward, with its net value considered zero in the distribution.
In some cases, a distressed property may have non-financial value—such as providing stability for children—that influences who keeps it. When one spouse retains such a property, they may also assume the debt associated with it, which can affect the division of other marital assets.
When a Distressed Property Is a Debt
If a distressed property results in a deficiency balance after a deed-in-lieu or short sale, that deficiency is a liability. In equitable distribution, the court will consider whether it is marital or separate debt based on when it was incurred and whether it benefited both spouses.
Deficiency balances from marital property sales are often classified as marital debt if the mortgage was a marital obligation. However, if the property was separate and the debt did not benefit both spouses, the deficiency may be separate.
The Dual Nature of Distressed Property
A distressed property can simultaneously be an asset and a debt. The asset is the ownership interest, while the debt is the mortgage or any deficiency after sale. When the property is transferred to the lender or sold in a short sale, the asset is extinguished, but the debt may remain. The court must address both elements in the distribution order.
Deed-in-Lieu of Foreclosure in Divorce
A deed-in-lieu involves transferring title back to the lender to satisfy the mortgage. In some cases, the lender agrees to cancel the debt entirely. In others, the lender accepts the deed but reserves the right to collect a deficiency if the property sells for less than the mortgage balance.
From an equitable distribution perspective, the deed-in-lieu:
- Eliminates the asset from the marital estate.
- May resolve the marital debt if the lender waives the deficiency.
- Leaves open the question of how to allocate any remaining deficiency.
If the deficiency is waived, the net effect may be a neutral entry in the distribution schedule. If a deficiency remains, it must be classified and allocated like any other marital debt.
Short Sales in Divorce
In a short sale, the property is sold to a third party for less than the mortgage balance, with the lender’s consent. The lender may accept the sale proceeds as full satisfaction of the debt or may require the borrower(s) to sign a promissory note for the deficiency.
In divorce, a short sale can:
- Resolve the property ownership question.
- Leave a deficiency that becomes part of the marital debt calculation.
- Create post-separation obligations that may be treated as divisible debt if tied to marital property.
An Asheville divorce lawyer will pay close attention to the terms of the lender’s approval to determine whether the deficiency is waived, negotiated, or remains enforceable.
Allocation of Deficiency Balances
When a deficiency remains after a deed-in-lieu or short sale, the court will consider:
- Timing: If the mortgage was incurred during the marriage, the deficiency is more likely to be marital.
- Benefit: If the property was used as a marital home or produced income for the marriage, the debt is likely marital.
- Agreement: If the parties agreed in a separation agreement that one would be responsible for the property, the court may enforce that allocation.
The court can divide the deficiency equally or unequally, depending on the overall fairness of the distribution.
Post-Separation Deficiency as Divisible Debt
If the property is sold or transferred after the date of separation, the deficiency may be considered divisible debt if it arises from a marital asset. This classification allows the court to allocate it in the final distribution even though it was incurred after separation.
Documentation is critical to show the connection between the marital property and the post-separation deficiency.
Negotiating Distressed Property in Divorce Settlements
Settlement agreements can address distressed property and potential deficiencies in detail, including:
- Who will pursue the deed-in-lieu or short sale.
- How costs and fees will be paid.
- Who will be responsible for any deficiency.
- Whether the responsible spouse will refinance or otherwise indemnify the other.
Clear terms reduce the risk of future disputes and protect both parties from unexpected liabilities.
Protecting Credit During Distressed Property Transactions
Both deeds-in-lieu and short sales can negatively impact credit scores. In divorce, protecting credit may be as important as allocating financial responsibility. Steps to mitigate damage include:
- Ensuring both parties cooperate with the lender.
- Obtaining written confirmation of deficiency waivers.
- Closing the transaction before late payments accrue.
An Asheville divorce lawyer will coordinate with real estate professionals to align the timing and terms of the transaction with the divorce process.
Tax Implications
Forgiven mortgage debt may be taxable income under federal law unless an exclusion applies. In divorce, the allocation of potential tax liability for forgiven debt should be addressed alongside the allocation of the deficiency itself. Failure to account for tax consequences can undermine an otherwise fair settlement.
When One Spouse Wants to Keep the Property
If one spouse wishes to keep a distressed property, they must generally refinance to remove the other spouse from the mortgage. The refinance will pay off the original loan, and the new loan will be the sole responsibility of the retaining spouse. This can eliminate the distressed property issue for the non-retaining spouse but may require offsetting asset transfers to balance the distribution.
Litigation Over Distressed Property
When spouses cannot agree on how to handle distressed property, the court will decide. Litigation can involve:
- Valuation disputes over the property’s current market value.
- Disagreement over whether to attempt a sale, deed-in-lieu, or foreclosure.
- Arguments over responsibility for the deficiency.
Courts have discretion to order a sale and to allocate debts in a way that is equitable under the circumstances.
High-Asset Divorce and Distressed Property
In high-asset Asheville divorces, distressed properties may be part of a larger real estate portfolio. Decisions about one property can affect financing and cash flow for the entire portfolio. Coordinated legal and financial planning is essential to protect overall asset value and minimize debt exposure.
Strategic Considerations for Asheville Divorce Lawyers
When advising clients on deeds-in-lieu and short sales, an Asheville divorce lawyer will:
- Confirm whether the lender will waive the deficiency.
- Analyze whether the deficiency is marital, separate, or divisible.
- Consider the impact on other asset and debt allocations.
- Address credit and tax consequences.
- Ensure the divorce judgment or settlement agreement contains clear, enforceable terms.
The goal is to align the resolution of distressed property with the broader equitable distribution strategy, ensuring that the client is not left with unexpected liabilities.
FAQ
Can a deed-in-lieu eliminate all mortgage debt in divorce?
Yes, if the lender agrees to waive the deficiency. If not, any remaining balance may still be owed.
Is a deficiency after a short sale marital debt?
If the mortgage was a marital obligation, the deficiency is often classified as marital debt for equitable distribution.
What if the property is sold after separation?
The deficiency may be considered divisible debt if it arises from a marital property.
Can the court force a deed-in-lieu or short sale?
The court can order the sale of marital property, but cooperation with the lender is necessary for a deed-in-lieu or short sale.
Will a deed-in-lieu or short sale hurt my credit?
Yes, both can negatively impact credit, though often less than a foreclosure.
Can tax be owed on forgiven mortgage debt?
Yes, unless an exclusion applies. Tax implications should be addressed in the divorce settlement.
What if one spouse wants to keep the distressed property?
They must usually refinance to remove the other spouse from the mortgage.
Can deficiency balances be split unequally?
Yes, North Carolina courts divide debts equitably, not necessarily equally.
Does a separation agreement control who pays the deficiency?
Yes, if it is clear and enforceable, though it does not bind the lender.
Why hire an Asheville divorce lawyer for distressed property issues?
Because the classification, negotiation, and allocation of these debts require precise legal strategy to protect your financial future.
The McKinney Law Group: Strategic Solutions for Debt Division in Asheville
We take the guesswork out of dividing marital debt. Our Asheville legal team provides clear strategies for handling joint accounts, loans, and liabilities during divorce.
Call 828-929-0642 or email [email protected] to arrange a consultation.