Prenuptial agreements are contracts. Like all contracts, they are bound by the laws of the jurisdiction where they are created. But life moves. People marry in New York, relocate to Florida, then divorce ten years later in a Tampa courtroom. So what happens when your prenup was signed out of state, but you’re divorcing in Florida? Does Florida law apply? Does the original state law still matter? Will the agreement be enforced as written, or will it be dissected clause by clause under new rules?
These are not abstract questions. They are practical ones. If you plan to rely on a prenuptial agreement that was drafted and signed outside Florida, and you’re now living here or facing divorce in a Florida court, the language in that agreement may not be enough to protect you. Enforceability depends on many factors. The agreement’s origins, the wording of its choice-of-law provision, the fairness of its terms, and Florida’s public policy will all matter.
A Tampa prenup lawyer can examine your out-of-state agreement and explain where it stands under Florida law. Sometimes the contract will hold up. Sometimes it will not. This article explores what you need to know when a Florida court must decide whether to enforce a prenuptial agreement signed elsewhere.
Does Florida Enforce Prenups Signed in Other States?
Yes, often. Florida courts routinely enforce valid prenuptial agreements signed in other states. But the court will first examine whether the agreement meets Florida’s basic requirements. The state does not simply rubber-stamp contracts from elsewhere.
Florida law requires that:
- The prenup be in writing and signed
- Both parties enter voluntarily
- Full and fair financial disclosure is provided, unless explicitly waived in writing
- The agreement is not unconscionable
Even if the prenup complies with another state’s rules, Florida judges will assess it using Florida’s standards if the couple is now seeking divorce in Florida. This is where things can get complicated. A Tampa prenup lawyer will look closely at the agreement’s procedural history and how the terms hold up under Florida’s family law framework.
Choice of Law Clauses
Many prenuptial agreements include a clause specifying which state’s law governs the contract. This is called a choice-of-law provision. If your prenup says it is governed by Illinois law, for example, a Florida court will try to honor that clause. But it will not do so blindly.
Florida courts generally enforce choice-of-law clauses unless:
- The chosen law violates Florida public policy
- The agreement conflicts with Florida’s procedural rules
- The clause was inserted to sidestep protections that Florida would have provided
Even with a choice-of-law provision, the court may apply Florida law to decide whether the agreement is enforceable. Especially when it comes to spousal support, homestead property, or child-related provisions, Florida’s interest in protecting its residents may override the clause.
A Tampa prenup lawyer can assess how your agreement’s choice-of-law provision interacts with Florida’s statutory rules and whether that clause will hold up in court.
Example: A New Jersey Prenup Reviewed in Florida
Let’s say a couple signs a prenup in New Jersey. It waives alimony, assigns all property acquired during the marriage to separate accounts, and includes a choice-of-law clause designating New Jersey law. Ten years later, the couple moves to Tampa and files for divorce.
The Florida court will ask:
- Was the prenup properly executed under New Jersey law?
- Were both parties represented and given adequate disclosure?
- Are the terms consistent with Florida’s rules?
- Would enforcing the agreement violate Florida’s public policy?
If the agreement waives alimony entirely, and the less wealthy spouse is now ill, unemployed, or unable to support themselves, the Florida court may override the waiver. Florida retains the power to deny enforcement of unconscionable alimony waivers.
A Tampa prenup lawyer would advise both parties to review and potentially update the agreement after relocating to Florida, especially if one spouse now faces a drastically different financial position than when the document was signed.
Florida’s Public Policy on Key Issues
Certain rights cannot be waived or altered by prenup in Florida, or at least not without proper safeguards. Even if your prenup complies with the original state’s rules, Florida may refuse to enforce parts of it based on public interest.
Key areas include:
Alimony
Florida allows parties to waive alimony in a prenup. But the court may disregard that waiver if it leaves one spouse in poverty or on public assistance. This is not the case in every state. If your prenup is from a state that allows ironclad waivers without exception, Florida may still override it in certain situations.
Child Support and Custody
Florida does not allow prenuptial agreements to determine child support or parenting schedules. Any clause attempting to predetermine custody, time-sharing, or child-related expenses will be ignored by the court. Some other states are more lenient, but Florida strictly reserves these decisions for judicial discretion at the time of divorce.
Homestead Protections
Florida has strong constitutional protections for homestead property. A spouse cannot be entirely disinherited from the marital home without a valid waiver. If your prenup was signed in a state with no such protection, the waiver may not be valid unless it meets Florida’s waiver standards.
A Tampa prenup lawyer will examine each of these clauses and explain which ones are likely to be enforced and which may require revision.
Procedural Challenges to Out-of-State Prenups
A party may challenge the validity of an out-of-state prenup by claiming:
- They signed under duress or coercion
- They did not receive adequate financial disclosure
- They did not understand the agreement’s terms
- They lacked independent legal counsel
- They did not voluntarily waive disclosure in writing
Florida courts take these claims seriously. Judges want to know that the agreement was signed knowingly, voluntarily, and with access to critical information. If your out-of-state prenup was signed hastily, without full disclosure, or under family pressure, a Florida court may set it aside.
A Tampa prenup lawyer can help gather evidence of execution, disclosure, and voluntariness to support the agreement’s enforcement.
Burden of Proof in a Florida Enforcement Action
The spouse trying to enforce the prenup generally carries the burden of proof. They must show:
- The agreement exists
- The agreement is valid
- The agreement was executed properly
If the other spouse challenges the agreement, they must prove:
- Lack of voluntariness
- Inadequate disclosure
- Unconscionability
- Fraud or duress
A Tampa prenup lawyer will collect documents, correspondence, and other evidence to strengthen your position, whether you are enforcing or challenging the agreement.
Updating or Reaffirming Your Prenup After Moving to Florida
If you signed your prenup elsewhere and now live in Florida, it is not too late to update the agreement. A postnuptial agreement can reaffirm the terms of your original prenup while bringing it into compliance with Florida law.
A Florida-compliant postnup can:
- Reconfirm waivers of alimony, property division, and estate rights
- Add Florida-specific provisions regarding homestead or elective share
- Replace outdated or unenforceable clauses
- Prevent future disputes about interpretation or jurisdiction
A Tampa prenup lawyer can review your existing agreement and prepare a postnup that honors your intentions while satisfying Florida’s legal standards.
How the Court Will Analyze Your Agreement
A Florida judge analyzing an out-of-state prenup will typically move through these questions:
- Is the agreement in writing and signed?
- Was it voluntarily executed?
- Was there full and fair disclosure?
- Does it contain a valid choice-of-law clause?
- Does the agreement violate any Florida public policies?
- Has the agreement become unconscionable due to life changes?
- Is the agreement specific and unambiguous in its terms?
If the agreement passes these tests, the court is likely to enforce it. But if the document is vague, incomplete, or directly conflicts with Florida law, parts of it may be struck down.
A Tampa prenup lawyer can present legal arguments, case law, and expert testimony to support your interpretation and protect your rights.
Practical Steps to Protect Your Out-of-State Prenup in Florida
If you have a prenup signed in another state and now live in Florida, take the following steps:
- Locate the original agreement
Make sure you have a signed, dated copy with all exhibits and attachments. - Review the terms with a Florida attorney
A Tampa prenup lawyer can identify provisions that conflict with Florida law or create risk. - Evaluate the need for a postnup
If circumstances have changed, consider updating the agreement to reflect your current assets, goals, and domicile. - Coordinate with your estate planning documents
Make sure your will, trust, and beneficiary designations align with your prenuptial agreement. - Keep financial records
Maintain clear records of property ownership, asset transfers, and financial disclosures. - Avoid contradictory conduct
Don’t treat separate property as marital unless your agreement allows for that treatment.
FAQ
Will Florida enforce a prenup signed in another state?
Yes, if the agreement complies with Florida law and does not violate public policy.
What happens if my prenup uses a different state’s law?
Florida courts may honor a choice-of-law clause, but they will still refuse to enforce terms that conflict with Florida’s laws.
Can I waive alimony in a prenup signed outside Florida?
Yes, but Florida courts may override the waiver if it is unconscionable at the time of enforcement.
Do I need a new prenup if I moved to Florida?
Not always, but a postnup can reaffirm your existing agreement and bring it into alignment with Florida law.
What if my out-of-state prenup includes child custody provisions?
Florida will ignore any clauses that try to predetermine custody or child support. These issues are decided based on the child’s best interests.
Can I challenge a prenup signed in another state?
Yes. Florida allows challenges based on duress, fraud, lack of disclosure, or unconscionability.
Does Florida treat homestead property differently than other states?
Yes. Florida’s homestead laws are strict. Waivers must meet specific standards. An out-of-state prenup may not satisfy them.
Will the court consider how much time I had to review the prenup?
Yes. Timing, legal representation, and access to information all matter in determining voluntariness.
What if my prenup was fair when signed but feels unfair now?
Florida courts generally enforce prenups based on the conditions at the time of signing, not how things turned out later. But extreme hardship may lead to limited exceptions.
Should I talk to a Florida lawyer even if my prenup was created elsewhere?
Yes. A Tampa prenup lawyer can help assess the agreement’s enforceability under Florida law and reduce future risk.
The McKinney Law Group: Protect Your Tampa Business with a Custom Prenup
Owning a business before marriage? A prenup can help you preserve what you’ve built. We work with Tampa entrepreneurs and professionals to create tailored agreements that safeguard their interests.
Call 813-428-3400 or email [email protected] to get started.