How Delayed Earnings Impact Equitable Distribution in Florida
In Florida divorce proceedings, understanding each party’s full income picture is essential to ensure a fair division of assets, a just determination of alimony, and accurate calculation of child support. Unfortunately, when high-earning spouses anticipate divorce or are already involved in litigation, some resort to strategic income manipulation to reduce their financial obligations. One of the most common strategies is the use of delayed compensation or deferred income tactics.
These tactics can take many forms—ranging from postponed bonuses and commissions to deferred stock options or backdated retirement contributions. When not properly scrutinized, they can dramatically undervalue a spouse’s income, disrupt equitable distribution, and deprive the other spouse of assets or support they are legally entitled to receive.
A Tampa divorce lawyer with experience in uncovering financial deception can identify these tactics, present evidence to the court, and work with forensic accountants or compensation experts to bring hidden income to light.
What Is Delayed or Deferred Compensation?
Delayed or deferred compensation is income that is earned during the marriage but not paid or realized until a future date. It can include:
- Year-end bonuses
- Commission payments
- Performance-based incentive packages
- Executive compensation plans
- Stock options (both vested and unvested)
- Restricted stock units (RSUs)
- Deferred retirement contributions
- Phantom stock
- Non-qualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plans
- Severance packages contingent on future performance or tenure
While some of these forms of compensation are legitimate and standard in certain industries, they can also be manipulated to disguise true income or delay asset accumulation until after the divorce is finalized.
A Tampa divorce lawyer can investigate the timing and structure of these payments to determine whether they are being used to circumvent fair division.
Common Deferred Income Tactics Used in Divorce
There are several ways a financially sophisticated spouse may attempt to reduce their perceived income or conceal future payments during a divorce. These include:
1. Postponing Bonuses or Commissions
Employers and executives often have the ability to influence the timing of their own compensation. A spouse may:
- Ask their employer to delay issuing a performance bonus
- Defer commission payouts until the divorce is finalized
- Push incentive payments into the next fiscal year
These tactics create the illusion of lower income during the divorce, which can skew alimony and support calculations.
2. Delaying Business Distributions
Business owners may avoid taking distributions or salary during the divorce period in order to present artificially low income. Instead, they allow profits to accumulate within the business and plan to withdraw funds after the divorce is complete.
This can be particularly difficult to detect if the spouse is the sole manager of the business or if the records are not disclosed voluntarily.
3. Deferring Executive Compensation
High-level employees often receive compensation in the form of RSUs, stock options, or NQDC plans that vest over time. Some may accelerate the vesting schedule or intentionally delay triggering events to shield these assets from equitable distribution.
4. Timing Severance Agreements or Retirement Payouts
A spouse on the brink of retirement may negotiate severance that doesn’t take effect until after divorce. Likewise, executives may defer retirement contributions to future tax years, making it harder to divide the asset during divorce proceedings.
5. Hiding Income in Phantom Equity Arrangements
Some businesses create phantom stock or other incentive-based programs that mimic real equity without formal ownership. These may not appear in basic financial disclosure documents but represent substantial future income.
A Tampa divorce lawyer can issue discovery requests and work with valuation experts to uncover these less-visible forms of compensation.
Legal Framework in Florida: Equitable Distribution and Marital vs. Non-Marital Property
Under Florida Statutes §61.075, courts must equitably divide all marital assets and liabilities acquired during the marriage. This includes income that has been earned but not yet received—so long as it was earned during the marriage.
To determine whether a deferred compensation item is subject to division, courts evaluate:
- When the income was earned
- Whether the right to payment accrued during the marriage
- The vesting schedule of any stock options or RSUs
- The intent behind any deferral
- Whether the compensation is contingent or guaranteed
If the compensation was earned based on work performed during the marriage, it is generally treated as a marital asset, even if it is not paid until after the divorce.
A Tampa divorce lawyer can use these factors to argue for inclusion of delayed compensation in the marital estate.
Discovery Tools to Uncover Deferred Compensation
Because these tactics are often buried in employment contracts, tax records, or corporate documents, it is crucial to use discovery tools to uncover the full scope of deferred income. Effective methods include:
1. Subpoenas to Employers
Subpoenas can be sent directly to an employer to request:
- Employment contracts
- Bonus and commission plans
- Stock option agreements
- Performance evaluations tied to compensation
- Deferred compensation plan documents
2. Interrogatories and Requests for Production
These written discovery tools can be used to require the spouse to:
- Disclose all sources of current and future income
- Produce pay stubs, bonus award letters, and W-2s
- List all accounts, options, and stock grants
3. Depositions
Depositions of the spouse, HR personnel, or compensation administrators can uncover whether any payments were delayed and why. Inconsistent testimony may reveal bad faith.
4. Tax Returns and Supporting Documents
Form W-2, Schedule K-1, and 1099s can expose income that was realized in prior years and deferred in the current year. Footnotes in tax returns sometimes mention deferred compensation or retirement contributions.
5. Forensic Accountants and Compensation Experts
These professionals specialize in analyzing complex pay structures and can project the value of deferred compensation based on historical performance, vesting schedules, and industry benchmarks.
A Tampa divorce lawyer works closely with these experts to prepare the most persuasive case for inclusion of deferred income in property division or support awards.
How Courts Address Delayed Compensation in Divorce
Florida courts have wide discretion when addressing deferred income tactics. If the court determines that income or bonuses were intentionally deferred to reduce equitable distribution or support, it can:
- Impute income to the spouse based on historical earning trends
- Include the anticipated bonus or payout in the marital estate
- Adjust the property distribution in favor of the innocent spouse
- Award retroactive alimony or support once the compensation is paid
- Sanction the deceptive spouse with attorney’s fees or other penalties
In high-asset divorces, judges often look past technical payment dates and focus on the economic substance of the compensation. A Tampa divorce lawyer must be prepared to present evidence of intent, timing, and benefit received.
The Role of Income Imputation in Deferred Compensation Cases
If a spouse presents artificially low income due to deferred compensation, Florida courts may impute income. This means the court assumes a certain level of income for purposes of calculating alimony or child support, even if that income is not currently being received.
Courts may impute income based on:
- The spouse’s historical earnings
- Industry standards for the position
- Previous bonus history
- Stock performance and vesting schedules
- Evidence of income being intentionally deferred
A Tampa divorce lawyer can advocate for or against imputation, depending on the client’s position and the available financial evidence.
Addressing Deferred Income in Settlement Agreements
In cases that resolve through mediation or negotiated settlement, deferred income must be specifically addressed in the marital settlement agreement (MSA). The MSA should clearly state:
- Which spouse is entitled to bonuses or commissions earned but not yet paid
- How deferred compensation will be valued
- Whether stock options or RSUs are to be divided or waived
- How to handle income received after divorce but earned during the marriage
Failing to address deferred compensation in the MSA can lead to post-judgment disputes and litigation. A Tampa divorce lawyer will ensure that all known and potential future income sources are properly accounted for in the agreement.
Protecting Against Deferred Income Manipulation During Divorce
To guard against income suppression and deferred payment schemes, take proactive steps during the early stages of the divorce:
- File for Temporary Relief
Temporary alimony or child support can be ordered based on current need and prior income history, protecting against immediate financial hardship.
- Request Financial Restraining Orders
Courts can prohibit major financial moves, such as delaying bonuses or reallocating compensation, during the case.
- Monitor Compensation Trends
Compare year-over-year income and ask your attorney to investigate any significant drops that coincide with the timing of the divorce.
- Include Clawback Clauses
In your settlement agreement, include language that provides for a financial adjustment if one spouse later receives income that was earned during the marriage.
- Subpoena Full Compensation Packages
Get detailed documents directly from the employer—not just what the spouse chooses to produce.
A Tampa divorce lawyer will implement these safeguards to ensure your financial interests are protected throughout the case.
Stock Options and RSUs: Marital or Non-Marital?
One of the most complex forms of deferred compensation is equity-based pay. To determine whether stock options or restricted stock units (RSUs) are marital, courts consider:
- The date of the grant
- The vesting schedule
- Whether the option is contingent on future work
- The purpose of the compensation (e.g., for past performance vs. future incentive)
If granted during the marriage for services performed during the marriage, stock options are typically considered marital. However, options granted after the date of filing for divorce are usually treated as non-marital.
A Tampa divorce lawyer can use valuation formulas (such as the “time rule” or “coverture fraction”) to allocate stock options fairly and avoid post-divorce windfalls.
Red Flags That May Indicate Deferred Compensation Abuse
Watch for these warning signs that your spouse may be manipulating income:
- Bonuses or commissions that were regularly paid in prior years suddenly disappear
- The spouse claims income “will be lower this year” due to “market conditions”
- Corporate records show profits but no distributions are being made
- The spouse is heavily involved in the timing of their own compensation
- Large equity awards are set to vest shortly after the divorce is finalized
A Tampa divorce lawyer can conduct thorough financial discovery to test the legitimacy of these claims and identify concealed income.
When to Use Expert Witnesses
In deferred compensation cases, expert testimony can be critical. Useful expert witnesses include:
- Forensic accountants – to trace income and evaluate whether compensation was delayed intentionally
- Compensation experts – to analyze executive pay structures and project future income
- Valuation analysts – to appraise stock options, RSUs, and phantom stock
- Vocational evaluators – to determine a spouse’s earning capacity when income is underreported
These professionals provide credible, court-admissible opinions that a Tampa divorce lawyer can use to challenge or support income disclosures.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is deferred compensation always considered marital property?
Not always. It depends on when it was earned, when it vests, and the terms of the compensation plan. Income earned during the marriage is generally marital, even if not paid until later.
Can a spouse delay a bonus until after the divorce on purpose?
Yes, and it happens frequently. If proven, the court may impute income or include the bonus in the marital estate.
What if my spouse is self-employed and defers taking income?
Courts may look at business profitability and impute income if distributions or salary are intentionally withheld. Forensic accountants can help uncover these tactics.
Are stock options divided during divorce?
If granted or vested during the marriage, they are usually subject to equitable distribution. Future unvested options may be partially marital.
Can I ask for part of a bonus that hasn’t been paid yet?
Yes, if it was earned during the marriage. A Tampa divorce lawyer can argue that the anticipated bonus is a marital asset.
How do courts handle RSUs in divorce?
Courts may allocate RSUs based on time-based formulas. The key factor is whether the RSUs relate to past or future employment performance.
Can the court revisit compensation received after divorce?
If the income was earned during the marriage but paid after divorce, you may be able to reopen the case or seek enforcement under certain conditions.
What if deferred income affects child support?
The court may modify child support once the income is received, or it may impute income based on earning history and compensation structure.
Should I settle before all deferred compensation is revealed?
Not without full financial discovery. Settling prematurely may result in forfeiting your share of significant hidden income.
Do I need a lawyer to identify deferred income issues?
Absolutely. A Tampa divorce lawyer knows how to investigate compensation structures, issue discovery requests, and ensure all income is properly accounted for in court.
The McKinney Law Group: Fast, Affordable Uncontested Divorce in Tampa
Ready to move forward? Our team will help you complete your uncontested divorce quickly and cost-effectively—while making sure everything is handled correctly under Florida law.
Call 813-428-3400 or email [email protected] for a consultation.