Can You Subpoena Your Spouse’s Employer in a Florida Divorce Case?

Can You Subpoena Your Spouse’s Employer in a Florida Divorce Case?

Uncovering the Full Financial Picture When Income and Benefits Are in Question

In Florida divorce proceedings, the equitable distribution of assets, alimony awards, and child support determinations all hinge on a clear and accurate understanding of both parties’ income, benefits, and financial circumstances. Yet many spouses, especially in high-conflict or high-net-worth cases, deliberately downplay or misrepresent their true income. Whether they are salaried employees, commission-based workers, or receive substantial non-monetary benefits, uncovering the full scope of compensation can be challenging.

In these cases, one of the most powerful discovery tools available is the subpoena—particularly when directed at a spouse’s employer. When used properly, a subpoena can compel the production of employment records, compensation data, work schedules, and correspondence that contradict or confirm a spouse’s financial disclosures.

A seasoned Tampa divorce lawyer knows exactly how to use a subpoena to an employer as part of a broader strategy to ensure honesty, enforce disclosure rules, and protect the equitable outcome the court is obligated to provide under Florida law.

What Is a Subpoena in a Florida Divorce Case?

A subpoena is a legal document that requires a third party—like an employer, bank, or business partner—to provide testimony, produce documents, or both. In divorce cases, subpoenas are typically used to obtain information not voluntarily disclosed by the opposing party.

In the context of employment, a Tampa divorce lawyer may issue:

  • Subpoena Duces Tecum: Requires the employer to produce documents, such as pay stubs, W-2s, bonus records, or benefit statements.
  • Subpoena for Deposition: Compels an employer representative (such as HR personnel) to appear for questioning under oath.
  • Records Custodian Subpoena: Targets the person responsible for maintaining employment records, such as a payroll administrator.

In Florida, subpoenas are governed by the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, specifically Rules 1.410 and 1.351. These rules allow parties in a divorce action to seek records and testimony relevant to the case—even when held by third parties like employers.

Why Subpoena an Employer in a Florida Divorce Case?

Subpoenaing a spouse’s employer may be necessary when:

  • Your spouse refuses to provide full income documentation
  • You suspect unreported income, such as cash bonuses or commissions
  • You believe there are perks, benefits, or deferred compensation not disclosed
  • Your spouse owns or controls the business where they are “employed”
  • You need to verify employment history, hours worked, or job performance
  • There are inconsistencies between tax returns and claimed income

A Tampa divorce lawyer will evaluate whether the employer’s records are relevant to your claims or defenses and whether other discovery methods have failed to yield complete information.

What Kind of Information Can You Get From an Employer Subpoena?

The information obtainable through an employer subpoena is broad, but must be tailored to the facts of the case. Common requests include:

  1. Compensation Records
    • Pay stubs
    • W-2 forms
    • 1099s (for contractors or consultants)
    • Bonus and commission records
    • Overtime or shift differentials
    • Deferred compensation plan documents
  2. Employment Contracts and Agreements
    • Offer letters
    • Employment agreements
    • Stock option agreements
    • Non-compete or severance packages
  3. Workplace Benefits
    • Health insurance premiums (employer and employee share)
    • Retirement contributions (401(k), pension, matching)
    • Car allowances or expense reimbursements
    • Stock grants or restricted stock units (RSUs)
  4. Time and Attendance Logs
    • Work schedules and punch-in/out records
    • Paid time off and leave history
    • Travel or per diem reimbursements
  5. Communications
    • Emails or memos regarding job status, promotions, demotions, or terminations
    • Internal correspondence confirming income, job role, or schedule changes

In some cases, a Tampa divorce lawyer may also subpoena the employer to testify about policies regarding compensation, benefits, or reporting structures—especially if the spouse is self-employed through the business.

When Is It Appropriate to Subpoena a Spouse’s Employer?

Subpoenas should be issued thoughtfully, strategically, and only when they will provide relevant information that cannot be obtained through other discovery tools.

Appropriate scenarios include:

  • A spouse who claims low income but maintains a high-end lifestyle
  • Suspicion that bonuses, commissions, or other variable pay are being hidden
  • Disputes over whether employment was terminated or voluntarily left
  • The need to clarify the value and structure of executive compensation
  • Child support enforcement cases involving misrepresented income
  • Self-employed spouses who route their income through a business entity

In these situations, a Tampa divorce lawyer may determine that a subpoena to the employer is not only justified—but essential.

Legal Requirements and Procedure for Issuing a Subpoena in Florida

To properly issue a subpoena in Florida:

  1. Include Proper Form and Notice
    The subpoena must comply with Rule 1.410 and contain:
    • The name of the issuing court
    • The title of the action
    • The name of the person or entity being subpoenaed
    • The specific documents or testimony being requested
  2. Notice to Opposing Counsel or Party
    Under Rule 1.351(b), you must give 10 days’ written notice to the other party before serving a subpoena on a third party for documents. The other side may object and seek court intervention.
  3. Serve the Subpoena
    Subpoenas must be served by a process server, sheriff, or another authorized agent.
  4. Comply With Objections
    If the opposing party files a motion to quash, the court will hold a hearing to determine whether the subpoena is proper. A Tampa divorce lawyer will defend the relevance and necessity of the subpoena.
  5. Pay Witness Fees If Applicable
    If the subpoena requires live testimony, a nominal witness fee must be tendered.

Improperly issued subpoenas may be quashed, delayed, or lead to sanctions. A Tampa divorce lawyer ensures all procedural and substantive rules are followed.

Can You Subpoena an Employer Without Telling Your Spouse?

In most cases, no. Florida law requires you to provide prior written notice to the opposing party before issuing a subpoena to a third party, such as an employer. This allows the opposing side to object if the subpoena is overly broad, seeks irrelevant information, or violates privacy.

Exceptions exist only in rare cases, such as emergency circumstances where financial assets are being rapidly dissipated or if there is credible concern about document destruction. Even then, a Tampa divorce lawyer must seek court approval for expedited or ex parte relief.

Employer Reactions and Privacy Concerns

Employers are not parties to the divorce but are obligated to comply with valid subpoenas. However, they may object to:

  • Disclosing proprietary compensation structures
  • Revealing employee evaluations or private HR records
  • Producing large volumes of irrelevant documents

A Tampa divorce lawyer minimizes friction by:

  • Narrowing the scope of the subpoena to what is necessary
  • Communicating with the employer’s legal department when needed
  • Providing assurances that the documents will be kept confidential and used solely for litigation purposes

In some cases, protective orders can be entered to safeguard sensitive information.

Subpoenaing Employers in Cases Involving Business Ownership

In many high-asset Florida divorces, a spouse is both an owner and employee of their own company. Subpoenaing the “employer” may require third-party discovery to:

  • Identify how the spouse’s compensation is structured
  • Determine whether dividends, distributions, or perks are being disguised as business expenses
  • Examine the spouse’s control over reporting or document production

If the business is a closely held corporation or LLC, a Tampa divorce lawyer may subpoena the company’s accountant, payroll provider, or financial advisor to bypass potential conflicts.

Subpoenas in Child Support and Alimony Enforcement

When support obligations are being determined or enforced, employer subpoenas can help:

  • Verify current income for modification requests
  • Confirm whether a parent is willfully underemployed
  • Document employment benefits used to offset child support (e.g., free housing, car allowance)
  • Determine whether bonuses were paid but not reported

If an obligor parent claims they cannot pay support, but employer records show otherwise, the court may impute income, increase obligations, or impose enforcement penalties. A Tampa divorce lawyer uses employer subpoenas strategically in these proceedings.

Can Employers Be Forced to Testify in Divorce Cases?

Yes, but courts are cautious about disrupting business operations. Testimony is generally limited to:

  • Authenticating records
  • Explaining payroll or compensation terms
  • Clarifying job duties or schedule
  • Verifying employment status or changes

Live testimony from an employer’s representative may be necessary in cases involving fraud, false employment claims, or willful income suppression. A Tampa divorce lawyer must show the relevance and necessity of the testimony.

Using Employer Documents in Trial

Documents received through an employer subpoena can be introduced as evidence at trial if they are:

  • Properly authenticated
  • Relevant to the claims or defenses
  • Not hearsay or subject to exclusion

Documents like pay stubs, bonus letters, or stock grants are often used to:

  • Challenge the accuracy of financial affidavits
  • Support imputed income arguments
  • Rebut claims of hardship
  • Clarify business valuation issues

A Tampa divorce lawyer ensures these documents are admissible, properly marked as exhibits, and explained through expert or lay testimony when needed.

Common Employer Documents That Reveal Financial Misrepresentation

Examples of revealing documents include:

  • A pay stub showing a “discretionary bonus” not disclosed in court
  • An offer letter revealing $150,000 base salary while the spouse claimed $90,000
  • 401(k) matching statements showing employer contributions
  • Travel reimbursements or stipends treated as income
  • Equity compensation agreements omitted from financial affidavits

These records can have a profound impact on asset division, alimony, and support calculations. A Tampa divorce lawyer uses them to challenge deception and preserve the integrity of the court’s rulings.

FAQs

Can I subpoena my spouse’s employer in a Florida divorce case?
Yes. If the employer has relevant information or documents about income, benefits, or employment status, a Tampa divorce lawyer can issue a subpoena.

What kind of documents can I request from an employer?
Pay stubs, W-2s, employment contracts, bonus agreements, benefit statements, and time records are commonly requested.

Does my spouse have to be notified if I subpoena their employer?
Yes. Florida law requires notice to the opposing party before serving a subpoena on a third party.

What if my spouse’s employer refuses to respond to the subpoena?
The court can compel compliance. A Tampa divorce lawyer may file a motion to enforce the subpoena.

Can I subpoena my spouse’s employer if they are self-employed?
Yes, but you may also need to subpoena the business’s accountant, payroll provider, or records custodian to avoid biased or incomplete responses.

Is employer information relevant for alimony and child support?
Absolutely. Compensation data and benefits directly affect support calculations and financial need evaluations.

Can an employer be required to testify in court?
Yes, though courts may limit the scope. Testimony is typically used to authenticate documents or clarify employment facts.

Are employer communications admissible in divorce court?
They may be, if relevant and properly authenticated. Emails confirming bonuses, pay raises, or job changes can be powerful evidence.

Will an employer retaliate against my spouse if subpoenaed?
Employers must comply with lawful subpoenas but may take issue if the request is burdensome. A Tampa divorce lawyer will tailor the subpoena to minimize disruption.

Do I need a lawyer to issue an employer subpoena?
Yes. A Tampa divorce lawyer ensures the subpoena is legally valid, strategically sound, and tailored to uncover the information you need without overreach.

The McKinney Law Group: Experienced, Streamlined Uncontested Divorce in Tampa
An uncontested divorce still requires legal precision. Our team ensures that every document is filed correctly and every agreement is enforceable under Florida law.
Call 813-428-3400 or email [email protected] to begin your case today.