Prenuptial agreements, commonly known as “prenups,” are contracts entered into by couples before marriage to establish rights and responsibilities regarding property division, spousal support, and other financial matters in the event of divorce or death. While these agreements can be powerful tools to protect assets, streamline divorce proceedings, and provide peace of mind, their enforceability is not absolute.
In Florida, and particularly in Hillsborough County, prenuptial agreements are governed by the Florida Uniform Premarital Agreement Act (FUPAA). Tampa courts uphold prenups when they meet statutory requirements and fundamental fairness standards, but courts will also set aside agreements that are unconscionable or entered into under improper circumstances.
A well-drafted prenuptial agreement can save time, money, and stress—but only if it withstands legal scrutiny. This article explores the factors that determine the enforceability of prenuptial agreements in Tampa courts and outlines what individuals and attorneys must consider to create agreements that are built to last.
Legal Framework: Florida’s Uniform Premarital Agreement Act (FUPAA)
The FUPAA, codified in Florida Statutes § 61.079, governs prenuptial agreements in the state. Under the Act, parties may enter into a contract before marriage that becomes effective upon marriage. A prenuptial agreement can address a wide range of issues, including:
- Rights to property acquired before or during the marriage
- Management and control of property
- Disposition of property upon divorce, separation, or death
- Alimony or spousal support
- Estate planning arrangements
- Ownership of life insurance
- Choice of law governing the agreement
- Any other personal rights and obligations, as long as they don’t violate public policy or criminal law
For a Tampa divorce attorney, understanding how courts apply FUPAA in real-world scenarios is essential to both drafting and challenging these agreements.
Key Requirements for Enforceability
For a prenuptial agreement to be enforceable in Tampa courts, it must meet certain criteria:
- Voluntary Execution
Both parties must sign the agreement voluntarily. If a party was coerced, pressured, or misled into signing the agreement, a court may find it unenforceable. Evidence of duress, threats, or manipulation can render the agreement void. - Full and Fair Disclosure
Each party must provide full disclosure of their financial situation, including assets, debts, income, and obligations. If a party fails to disclose critical financial information and the other party did not waive disclosure in writing, the agreement may be set aside. - Independent Legal Counsel (Encouraged)
While not required, each party having independent legal counsel strengthens the enforceability of the agreement. Courts are more likely to uphold a prenup when both individuals were represented by separate attorneys. - No Unconscionability
A prenuptial agreement must not be unconscionable when it is executed. Courts examine whether the terms are so one-sided that enforcement would be fundamentally unfair. - Proper Execution
The agreement must be in writing and signed by both parties. Oral agreements are not enforceable, regardless of the parties’ intentions.
Timing and Execution: Why It Matters
One of the most common grounds for challenging a prenuptial agreement is the timing of its execution. Courts are wary of agreements signed under pressure shortly before a wedding. If a prenup is presented mere days before the ceremony, and the other party feels compelled to sign to avoid canceling the wedding, a judge may determine that the agreement was not entered into voluntarily.
Tampa divorce attorneys routinely advise clients to begin discussing and drafting prenuptial agreements months before the wedding date. This avoids allegations of coercion and allows ample time for negotiation, review, and revision.
Disclosure and Waiver: Navigating the Risk
Full financial disclosure is one of the most important elements of a valid prenuptial agreement. Each party should provide a detailed statement of their financial status. This includes:
- Real estate holdings
- Business interests
- Retirement accounts
- Investment portfolios
- Personal property of significant value
- Outstanding debts
While Florida law allows a party to waive the right to financial disclosure, this waiver must be explicit and in writing. Even then, if the court finds that the party did not have adequate knowledge of the other’s finances and the agreement was unconscionable, it may be invalidated.
Tampa courts frequently scrutinize prenups that lack meaningful disclosure, especially if the result heavily favors one party over the other.
Unconscionability: A High Bar, But Still a Risk
An unconscionable prenuptial agreement is one that is so lopsided that enforcing it would be unjust. While courts generally respect the autonomy of parties to contract, they will not enforce agreements that shock the conscience of the court.
Examples of provisions that may trigger a finding of unconscionability include:
- Complete waiver of alimony for a spouse who is left without any means of support
- One-sided terms that allow only one party to keep all assets acquired during the marriage
- Provisions that penalize a spouse for seeking a divorce
Florida courts typically determine unconscionability based on the circumstances at the time the agreement was executed, not at the time of divorce. A Tampa divorce attorney will review financial disclosures, legal representation, and the fairness of the terms when determining whether a prenup is at risk of being struck down.
Challenging a Prenuptial Agreement in Tampa
If a prenuptial agreement is challenged during a divorce, the court will hold an evidentiary hearing to determine its validity. The burden of proof is on the party seeking to invalidate the agreement. They must demonstrate that:
- The agreement was not signed voluntarily; or
- The agreement was unconscionable, and they were not provided fair disclosure, did not waive the right to disclosure, and lacked adequate knowledge of the other party’s finances.
In Tampa courts, judges will carefully examine the totality of the circumstances, including:
- Timing of the agreement’s presentation and signing
- The presence (or absence) of legal counsel
- The level of financial disclosure
- The experience and sophistication of the parties
- Any evidence of fraud, duress, or undue influence
What Prenuptial Agreements Cannot Do
While prenuptial agreements can cover a wide array of financial topics, there are limits. A prenup cannot:
- Predetermine child custody or time-sharing arrangements
- Waive child support
- Include terms that violate public policy or criminal laws
- Impose personal lifestyle requirements (e.g., weight gain clauses, sexual frequency clauses)
Even if the parties agree on these matters, Florida courts will not enforce them. A Tampa divorce attorney ensures that prenuptial agreements stay within the bounds of enforceable content to avoid future challenges.
Prenups and Alimony: Waivers Must Be Clear
Alimony provisions are among the most commonly litigated aspects of prenuptial agreements. Florida law allows parties to waive or limit alimony, but only if the waiver is clear, unambiguous, and not unconscionable.
Key considerations for courts evaluating an alimony waiver:
- Did the waiving party understand the implications?
- Was there full disclosure of the other party’s income and assets?
- Would the waiver leave the spouse destitute or dependent on public assistance?
If the answer to any of these questions raises concern, a Tampa divorce attorney may advise amending or restructuring the alimony provisions to improve enforceability.
Choice of Law Provisions: Can You Select Florida Law?
Prenuptial agreements often include a choice of law clause specifying which state’s laws will govern the contract. In Tampa courts, such provisions are generally upheld as long as:
- The chosen law has a substantial relationship to the parties or the agreement
- The application of that law does not violate Florida’s public policy
Selecting Florida law for a prenup executed by Florida residents intending to marry and live in Florida is both logical and enforceable. However, where other jurisdictions are involved, a Tampa divorce attorney must assess whether the foreign law contradicts key Florida policies.
Postnuptial Agreements: Different Rules, Different Risks
While this article focuses on prenuptial agreements, it’s worth noting that postnuptial agreements—entered into after marriage—are subject to slightly different scrutiny. Because spouses have a fiduciary duty to one another, postnups require a higher level of fairness and transparency. Courts are more likely to question postnuptial agreements that significantly favor one spouse or lack meaningful disclosure.
A Tampa divorce attorney reviewing both types of agreements must be aware of the differing standards and expectations applied by the courts.
Reformation and Partial Enforcement
Florida courts have the power to sever unenforceable provisions from a prenuptial agreement and enforce the rest. This is known as partial enforcement. Courts may also “reform” an agreement to reflect the parties’ intent, provided it does not require the court to rewrite the contract.
For example, if a court finds that an alimony waiver is unenforceable but the property division provisions are fair and clearly stated, the court may uphold the rest of the agreement.
A Tampa divorce attorney can argue for reformation or partial enforcement to preserve the agreement’s intended effect, even if one provision fails.
Best Practices for Creating Enforceable Prenuptial Agreements
- Start Early
Give both parties ample time to review, revise, and understand the agreement. Avoid signing days or hours before the wedding. - Exchange Full Financial Disclosures
Include schedules of assets, liabilities, income, and anticipated inheritances. This transparency is key to enforceability. - Use Separate Attorneys
Independent legal representation ensures both parties understand their rights and helps demonstrate voluntariness. - Avoid One-Sided Terms
Fairness matters. Courts are more likely to enforce agreements that provide benefits and obligations for both parties. - Put Everything in Writing
Oral understandings are not enforceable. Ensure all agreed-upon terms are clearly written and executed. - Update Agreements as Needed
If circumstances change significantly—such as after children are born or a business expands—consider revising the agreement or executing a postnup.
A Tampa divorce attorney plays a vital role in guiding parties through these steps and crafting an agreement that meets legal standards while serving the clients’ needs.
FAQ: Enforceability of Prenuptial Agreements in Tampa
Is a prenuptial agreement enforceable in Tampa if only one party had an attorney?
Yes, but the absence of legal counsel for one party may raise questions about voluntariness and understanding. Courts prefer that both parties are represented to ensure fairness.
Can a prenuptial agreement waive alimony entirely?
Yes, but the waiver must be clear, based on full disclosure, and not unconscionable. If enforcing the waiver would leave a spouse impoverished, courts may override it.
How far in advance of the wedding should a prenup be signed?
There is no specific rule, but signing well in advance—ideally at least a month before the wedding—helps demonstrate voluntariness and avoid claims of duress.
Can a prenup cover child custody and support?
No. Child custody and child support cannot be predetermined in a prenuptial agreement. These issues are decided based on the child’s best interest at the time of divorce.
What happens if financial disclosure is incomplete?
If a party did not receive fair disclosure and did not waive it in writing, the agreement may be invalidated—especially if the result is unfair or one-sided.
Can a Tampa court enforce a prenup signed in another state?
Yes, as long as the agreement complies with that state’s laws and does not violate Florida public policy. A choice of law provision may also influence enforceability.
What if the prenup was signed the day before the wedding?
While not automatically invalid, last-minute execution may raise concerns about coercion or inadequate time for review. Courts will examine the specific facts.
Can a prenup protect business interests?
Yes. A prenup can specify that business interests remain separate property and define how appreciation or income from the business will be handled.
Are lifestyle clauses enforceable?
No. Courts generally will not enforce provisions that control personal behavior, such as requirements about appearance, fidelity, or household duties.
Is it too late to create a prenup after the engagement?
No. A prenuptial agreement can be created anytime before marriage, but earlier is better to avoid claims of pressure or haste.
Conclusion
The enforceability of prenuptial agreements in Tampa courts depends on how carefully and transparently they are prepared. Voluntariness, disclosure, fairness, and compliance with legal standards are critical. A solid prenup can protect assets, reduce conflict, and provide clarity for both parties—but only if it stands up in court.
A Tampa divorce attorney can help ensure that your prenuptial agreement is not only valid, but also strategically crafted to withstand legal scrutiny and support your long-term goals. Whether you’re drafting a new agreement or facing a challenge to an existing one, understanding how Tampa courts evaluate these contracts is essential to protecting your future.
The McKinney Law Group: Divorce Services That Fit Your Schedule and Budget
Divorce shouldn’t break your routine—or your bank account. At The McKinney Law Group, we offer flexible, efficient services for Tampa clients, whether your case is simple or more involved.
We offer:
✔ Flat-fee uncontested divorce options
✔ Payment plans for eligible clients
✔ Virtual consultations and flexible hours
✔ Step-by-step guidance with transparent pricing
Call 813-428-3400 or email [email protected] to learn more.