Florida: (813) 906-0048 (813) 906-0048
North Carolina: (828) 929-0642
(813) 906-0048
Florida: (813) 906-0048 (813) 906-0048

How to Modify a Custody Order When a Child Refuses Timesharing

How to Modify a Custody Order When a Child Refuses Timesharing

How to Modify a Custody Order When a Child Refuses Timesharing

When it comes to Florida family law, one of the most pressing and emotionally charged issues parents face is timesharing—who the child stays with, when they stay there, and how often they transition between households. Court-ordered timesharing schedules are designed to ensure that both parents maintain meaningful contact and involvement in the child’s life. But what happens when the child, for one reason or another, refuses to spend time with one parent? Can you modify a custody order to address this situation, and if so, how should you proceed?

This post explores the circumstances under which a Florida parent might seek to modify an existing custody order due to a child’s refusal of timesharing. We’ll look at the legal framework, common reasons why children resist visits, and the steps you can take to protect both your child’s well-being and your legal standing. Finally, we’ll discuss how a Tampa divorce lawyer can provide essential guidance in navigating the complexities of petitioning the court for a modification.

Understanding Florida’s Timesharing Framework

Under Florida law, the term “custody” has largely been replaced by “parenting plans” and “timesharing schedules.” Florida courts believe that children generally benefit from having frequent and continuing contact with both parents, except in cases where such contact would be harmful. This belief is codified in Florida Statutes §61.13, which outlines how courts determine parental responsibility and timesharing arrangements.

A court-approved parenting plan typically addresses:

  1. Decision-Making Authority: Who has responsibility for major decisions affecting the child’s health, education, and welfare
  2. Timesharing Schedule: How much time each parent spends with the child during the week, weekends, holidays, and vacations
  3. Communication Methods: Guidelines for phone calls, video calls, and other forms of contact between the child and each parent

Once the court issues a final order incorporating this parenting plan, both parents are legally obligated to comply. If either parent does not follow the schedule or otherwise fails to honor the plan’s provisions, the other parent can file a motion for contempt or enforcement. However, the scenario becomes more complicated if a child independently refuses to visit the other parent. The key question then becomes whether this refusal justifies—or necessitates—a legal modification to the existing custody order.

Why Children May Refuse Timesharing

A child’s reluctance or outright refusal to visit one parent can stem from a wide range of causes. Understanding these underlying reasons is often the first step in deciding how to address the problem legally and emotionally.

  1. Emotional Distress: Divorce or separation can be traumatic. Children may feel anxiety, sadness, or confusion, which can manifest as resistance to leaving their primary residence.
  2. Fear or Safety Concerns: In extreme situations, the child may have experienced abuse or neglect, leading them to feel unsafe with the other parent.
  3. Alienation: One parent may, deliberately or inadvertently, speak negatively about the other parent or discourage the child from forming a bond with them. This phenomenon, known as parental alienation, can lead a child to refuse visits.
  4. Adolescent Autonomy: Teenagers, in particular, may assert independence by choosing not to visit. They might prefer to stay with friends or keep their social lives intact rather than switch between homes.
  5. Logistical or Routines-Related Issues: A child may have extracurricular activities, friendships, or academic demands that make traveling between homes feel disruptive.

Whatever the root cause, the law typically expects both parents to encourage compliance with the court-ordered schedule. That includes proactively fostering the child’s relationship with the other parent. If, despite all efforts, the child still refuses to participate in timesharing, a petition to modify the existing order might become necessary.

The Legal Standard for Modifying Custody Orders

Florida courts do not modify custody orders lightly. Generally, to modify an existing parenting plan or timesharing schedule, you must show:

  1. A Substantial, Material, and Unanticipated Change in Circumstances: This change must be significant enough to affect the child’s well-being or the workability of the existing plan. A child’s ongoing refusal to visit one parent may fall under this umbrella, but only if the refusal is not fleeting and is tied to a real, substantive issue.
  2. Best Interests of the Child: Even if the child refuses visits, the court still adheres to the principle that, barring safety or neglect concerns, maintaining relationships with both parents is typically in the child’s best interests. If a modification is sought, the proposed change must align with this paramount consideration.

The difficulty is proving that the child’s resistance to timesharing represents a substantial and material change. If the refusal stems from normal teenage angst or a temporary conflict, the court may view it as insufficient for altering the entire parenting plan. On the other hand, if there is evidence of abuse, severe emotional distress, or an irreparable breakdown in the parent-child relationship, a judge might be more inclined to consider a modification.

Scenarios That May Justify Modification

  1. Documented Abuse or Neglect: If the child has reported incidents of abuse, neglect, or mistreatment by the non-custodial parent, this can be a powerful reason to seek a court-ordered modification—perhaps restricting or requiring supervised visitation.
  2. Severe Mental Health Struggles: If the child is experiencing serious mental health issues, such as anxiety, depression, or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), triggered or exacerbated by visits to the other parent, a court might consider adjusting the schedule. It is crucial to have documentation from mental health professionals to support such claims.
  3. Evidence of Parental Alienation: If it is shown that the custodial parent (or, in some cases, the non-custodial parent) has engaged in parental alienation, the court may modify the order to protect the child’s best interests. In extreme cases, the court might even transfer majority timesharing to the alienated parent.
  4. Recurrent Non-Compliance by the Non-Custodial Parent: If the non-custodial parent repeatedly misses scheduled visits, fails to communicate, or creates an environment that the child finds highly unstable, the custodial parent can argue for a revised plan that better suits the child’s emotional and psychological needs.
  5. Child’s Age and Capacity: While Florida does not have a specific age at which a child can decide not to visit a parent, the courts do give more weight to the preferences of older teenagers who can articulate valid reasons for their refusal.

Documenting the Child’s Refusal

Before rushing to court to request a modification, you should thoroughly document the child’s refusal, including all relevant circumstances and any efforts you have made to encourage compliance. This documentation can become vital if the other parent accuses you of contempt or alienation. Here are some steps you might take:

  1. Written Records: Keep a journal or log detailing each time the child refuses to go, what the child says, and how you respond. Include dates, times, and any specific complaints or concerns your child voices.
  2. Communications with the Other Parent: Document text messages, emails, or phone conversations in which you discuss the child’s refusal. If you have been cooperative and transparent, this will help demonstrate that you have not been willfully obstructing timesharing.
  3. Professional Assessments: If possible, get a licensed counselor or therapist involved, especially if the child is experiencing anxiety, fear, or emotional turmoil. A professional can evaluate the child’s perspective and offer insight into whether modifying the plan is indeed in the child’s best interests.
  4. Witness Statements: Teachers, coaches, or other adults who interact with your child may notice changes in behavior or mood during times of increased conflict. Their statements can corroborate your claim that the child’s refusal is serious and not a manipulative tactic.

The Role of Mediation and Collaborative Approaches

In many Florida jurisdictions, parents are required to attempt mediation before proceeding to a final hearing on custody matters. Mediation can be especially helpful when a child’s refusal to visit is rooted in misunderstandings, unspoken resentments, or communication breakdowns between parents.

  1. Neutral Environment: Mediation provides a safe and structured setting in which both parents—and possibly the child, if appropriate—can discuss the issues.
  2. Child-Focused Solutions: A skilled mediator can steer the discussion toward finding solutions that serve the child’s best interests. This might include adjusting the timesharing schedule to reduce stress on the child, or adding measures like counseling or supervised visitation if there are safety concerns.
  3. Voluntary Agreements: If both parents can reach an agreement on how to address the child’s refusal, that agreement can be submitted to the court for approval. This is often faster and less contentious than litigating a modification.
  4. Reduced Conflict: By communicating openly, parents may discover that the child’s resistance is based on concerns that can be remedied without dramatic legal battles.

Additionally, collaborative family law is another alternative dispute resolution method that aims to keep matters out of court through a cooperative approach involving attorneys, mental health professionals, and financial advisors. While collaborative law might not be suitable for every situation—particularly those involving allegations of abuse—it can be highly effective for parents who genuinely want to find a child-centered solution to timesharing problems.

Filing a Petition to Modify the Custody Order

If informal measures and mediation fail, you may decide to file a petition for modification. The process typically involves:

  1. Drafting the Petition: You or your Tampa divorce lawyer will prepare a legal document, usually titled “Petition for Modification of Final Judgment of Dissolution of Marriage,” explaining the specific changes you are requesting and why they are justified by a substantial and material change in circumstances.
  2. Supporting Documentation: Attach any evidence that supports your claim—such as therapist evaluations, copies of written communications, and affidavits from relevant witnesses.
  3. Filing and Serving the Other Parent: You will file the petition with the clerk of court in the county where the original custody order was issued (or where the child currently resides, depending on the circumstances). The other parent must be formally served with these documents.
  4. Response from the Other Parent: The other parent has the right to file an answer or counter-petition. They may argue that there has not been a substantial change, or that the child’s refusal is the result of your actions.
  5. Court Proceedings: If you cannot settle the matter through mediation or negotiation, the case will proceed to a hearing or trial. Both sides will present evidence, witnesses, and arguments. The judge will make a determination based on the best interests of the child and the credibility of each party’s evidence.

Defending Against Contempt

Parents who try to modify a custody order because of a child’s refusal often face accusations of contempt. The other parent might claim that you’ve been “willfully” disobeying the timesharing schedule. Here’s how you can protect yourself:

  1. Good-Faith Efforts: Show that you have been doing your best to comply with the court order. Explain how you encouraged the child to visit, transported them to meeting points, or engaged in counseling to resolve underlying issues.
  2. Clear Communication: Provide proof of text messages, emails, or calls to the other parent in which you attempted to discuss the child’s concerns. This helps rebut claims that you are blocking contact.
  3. Professional Recommendations: Present medical or psychological evaluations that support the notion that forcing the child to visit could be detrimental. If professionals advised you to seek a modification or to reduce visits temporarily, that could be a valid defense.

Successfully defending yourself against contempt depends largely on demonstrating that you have been proactive and transparent, rather than standing idly by while the child refuses visits.

Working with a Tampa Divorce Lawyer

Navigating the legal system can be overwhelming, especially when you’re also dealing with the emotional weight of a child’s refusal to engage in court-ordered timesharing. Hiring a Tampa divorce lawyer who has handled similar cases can significantly reduce the stress and uncertainty. Here’s how an attorney can assist:

  1. Case Evaluation: A lawyer can quickly assess whether your child’s refusal constitutes a substantial and material change that might justify a court modification. They can also advise if alternative routes (like mediation) should be tried first.
  2. Petition Drafting: Legal documents must be precise, well-organized, and presented in a format acceptable to the court. Your attorney can craft a petition that lays out your case convincingly.
  3. Evidence Collection: Gathering and preserving evidence is critical in modification cases. An attorney can help you obtain therapist records, witness statements, and other documentation, ensuring it meets evidentiary standards.
  4. Negotiation and Mediation: A seasoned family law attorney is skilled in negotiation, which can help you reach a more favorable agreement without a protracted court battle.
  5. Court Representation: If your case does go to trial, your lawyer will present arguments, cross-examine witnesses, and make a compelling case before the judge.

Given the unique complexities of Florida’s family law, including local procedural rules and judges’ preferences, working with an attorney who is well-versed in Tampa-area courts can be a critical asset.

Balancing Child Autonomy and Parental Responsibilities

One of the most challenging aspects of modifying a custody order due to a child’s refusal is striking the right balance between respecting the child’s feelings and upholding parental obligations.

  • Respect for the Child’s Voice: Older children and teens can articulate their reasons for not wanting to visit. Florida courts increasingly consider the views of children as they grow older, though these views are not the sole factor in making a decision.
  • Parental Duty to Encourage: Even if the child has valid concerns, a parent is still expected to facilitate timesharing. You cannot simply allow the child to stop visiting on a whim. Showing consistent efforts to resolve conflicts can strengthen your case for a modification if one is truly needed.

If the child’s refusal arises from legitimate fear or discomfort, it’s essential to address the problem rather than ignore it. This might involve therapy, supervised visits, or temporarily adjusted schedules until the underlying issues are resolved.

The Importance of Mental Health Support

When a child persistently refuses to visit a parent, emotions can run high on all sides. Consulting with a mental health professional—whether it’s a counselor, psychologist, or psychiatrist—can offer several benefits:

  1. Diagnosing Underlying Issues: A professional can help determine if the refusal stems from anxiety, trauma, or other psychological factors.
  2. Reducing Conflict: Therapy can be a neutral space where family members voice concerns openly. Sometimes, just having an impartial third party facilitate discussions can ease tension.
  3. Establishing Credibility: Courts often give weight to the opinions and recommendations of qualified mental health professionals. If a therapist corroborates that the child has strong reasons for not wanting to visit, the court is more likely to consider a modification.
  4. Long-Term Solutions: Even if a modification is granted, the ultimate goal should be resolving the root cause of the child’s refusal so that both parent-child relationships can heal and thrive.

Strategies for a Smooth Transition (If Modification Is Granted)

If you successfully obtain a modified custody order that changes the timesharing schedule, the work doesn’t stop there. Implementing the new arrangement in a way that supports the child’s mental health is crucial.

  1. Gradual Adjustments: Instead of jumping from one schedule to another overnight, consider a phased approach. For example, you might start with daytime visits instead of overnights if the child is uncomfortable.
  2. Consistent Routines: Children need stability and predictability. If the new schedule is complex, use a shared calendar or apps designed for co-parenting to keep everyone on the same page.
  3. Positive Reinforcement: Encourage the child when they engage with the new arrangement. Offer praise or simple rewards (not bribes) for following the schedule, helping them feel secure.
  4. Open Communication: Keep the lines of communication open with the other parent. Even if the relationship is strained, discussing logistics and addressing concerns promptly can reduce misunderstandings that fuel the child’s anxiety.
  5. Continued Counseling: If therapy played a role in helping the child navigate emotional challenges, maintaining that support can help them adapt more smoothly to any changes.

Pitfalls to Avoid

  1. Self-Help Measures: Unilaterally deciding to stop visitation without a court order can lead to contempt charges. Always work within the legal framework.
  2. Parental Alienation: Even unintentionally making disparaging remarks about the other parent in front of the child can damage your credibility in court and harm the child’s emotional health.
  3. Ignoring the Child’s Feelings: Forcing the child to comply without addressing the root issues can deepen their resistance. Courts look for parents who try to solve problems, not just enforce rules.
  4. Delay in Taking Action: If the child’s refusal is persistent and you suspect the current order isn’t working, don’t wait until the other parent files a motion for contempt. Proactively seeking a modification can show the court that you’re acting in good faith.
  5. Failing to Seek Legal Advice: Family law is complicated. Missteps can be costly, both financially and emotionally. Consulting a Tampa divorce lawyer early in the process can save you from bigger problems later.

Realistic Expectations

It’s important to have realistic expectations when attempting to modify a custody order because a child refuses timesharing. Courts typically presume that regular contact with both parents is beneficial. Unless there’s compelling evidence that these visits are detrimental, you may not get the drastic changes you’re seeking.

  • Partial Adjustments: The judge might order slightly reduced timesharing or impose conditions like supervised visits rather than eliminating contact altogether.
  • Temporary vs. Permanent: The court could issue a temporary order, especially if the child’s refusal appears to be tied to a resolvable issue.
  • Ongoing Reviews: In some cases, the court retains jurisdiction to review how the child is adjusting to any modifications, making additional tweaks if necessary.

Remember, the court’s primary focus is the child’s best interests, which often means fostering a relationship with both parents unless there’s a compelling reason not to.

Co-Parenting Communication Tips

Modifying a custody order is much easier when both parents are willing to cooperate. If the other parent is open to negotiation, use these communication tips to keep the conversation constructive:

  1. Keep Emotions in Check: Heated discussions rarely lead to positive resolutions. Take breaks if you feel overwhelmed or angry.
  2. Use “I” Statements: Instead of accusing the other parent—“You never care about our child’s feelings!”—try phrasing concerns with “I” statements, such as, “I’m worried about how anxious our child seems before visits.”
  3. Focus on the Child: Continually bring the discussion back to what is best for the child, rather than airing personal grievances.
  4. Stay Organized: Use co-parenting apps or shared calendars to avoid miscommunications about scheduling changes or appointments.
  5. Seek Third-Party Help: If conversations keep spiraling, consider bringing in a mediator or co-parenting counselor to facilitate dialogue.

When Court Intervention Becomes Necessary

Despite your best efforts at mediation, communication, and counseling, sometimes court intervention is unavoidable. Here are a few red flags indicating that you might need a judge to step in:

  • Allegations of Abuse: If there are credible reports of physical or emotional abuse, the court must be notified immediately for the child’s protection.
  • Intractable Conflict: If one parent refuses to cooperate with any alternative dispute resolution measures and the child’s well-being is at stake, a judicial ruling may be the only solution.
  • Parental Alienation Evidence: In extreme cases where alienation has severely harmed the parent-child relationship, a judge might be the only authority capable of imposing a remedy.
  • Threats of Contempt: If the other parent is threatening legal action against you for non-compliance, you may need the court’s clarification or modification to avoid unfair penalties.

How a Tampa Divorce Lawyer Prepares for Court

If your custody-modification case escalates to a judicial hearing, thorough preparation is essential. Here is how a Tampa divorce lawyer typically prepares for a court date in these situations:

  1. Reviewing Documentation: They will go over every piece of evidence—your journal of refusals, text messages, emails, and any professional evaluations.
  2. Securing Witnesses: Your lawyer may identify teachers, therapists, or family friends who can testify about the child’s behavior and interactions with the other parent.
  3. Developing a Strategy: Based on your goals and the child’s best interests, your lawyer will form a legal strategy to present a strong argument for modifying the existing order.
  4. Preparing You for Testimony: Testifying in court can be nerve-wracking. An experienced attorney will coach you on how to respond calmly and factually to cross-examination.
  5. Negotiation Skills: Even on the brink of a hearing, negotiations can still happen. Your attorney may work with the opposing side to reach a settlement that avoids a full trial.

Long-Term Outlook After Modification

Once a modification is granted—assuming the court finds that circumstances warrant an adjusted parenting plan—the journey isn’t over. As life goes on, children grow older, needs evolve, and new issues may arise. Here are some considerations for the long-term:

  1. Monitoring the Child’s Adaptation: Pay close attention to how the child reacts to the new schedule. Are they more at ease? Are conflicts with the other parent subsiding or continuing?
  2. Continued Use of Resources: Therapy, mediation check-ins, and parenting coordination can remain valuable tools for navigating post-modification life.
  3. Future Modifications: Remember that a custody order can be revisited if new substantial changes occur, such as relocation, remarriage, or a significant shift in the child’s needs.
  4. Maintaining Positive Co-Parenting: Strive to keep lines of communication open to prevent small disagreements from escalating into major legal battles again.
  5. Encouraging the Parent-Child Bond: Even if the schedule is reduced or changed, continue to encourage a healthy relationship between the child and the other parent, unless doing so poses a genuine risk.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can I modify a custody order just because my child dislikes visiting the other parent?
Not necessarily. A general dislike or mild discomfort is usually not enough for a Florida court to consider this a substantial and material change. You must show evidence that the child’s refusal to visit significantly affects their well-being, or that other important factors—like abuse or alienation—have come into play.

2. Will the judge automatically reduce the other parent’s timesharing if my child refuses visits?
No. Florida courts aim to preserve relationships with both parents whenever possible. If the refusal is not rooted in serious concerns (e.g., abuse, severe neglect), the judge is unlikely to eliminate or drastically reduce timesharing without exploring alternatives, such as therapy or mediation.

3. What if my teenager flatly refuses to go, and I don’t want to force them physically?
You are not typically required to use physical force to make your child comply. However, the court expects you to make reasonable efforts—such as communication, reassurance, and counseling—to encourage the child’s participation. Document these efforts, as they can protect you from contempt claims.

4. Can I ask for supervised visitation if my child is afraid of the other parent?
Yes, if you have valid concerns about the child’s safety or emotional well-being, you may request supervised visitation as part of the modification. You must present evidence—such as police reports, therapist evaluations, or expert testimony—to support this request.

5. How long does it take to modify a custody order in Florida?
The timeline varies depending on the complexity of the case, the court’s docket, and whether both parents are cooperating. In general, it can take anywhere from a few weeks (if both sides settle quickly) to several months or longer if a trial becomes necessary.

Modifying a custody order when a child refuses timesharing is a significant legal undertaking that requires careful documentation, clear evidence of a substantial change, and a child-centered approach. Florida courts recognize that life after divorce is dynamic and that children’s needs can evolve over time. However, they also uphold the principle that, whenever safe and feasible, children benefit from maintaining meaningful relationships with both parents.

If you believe your situation meets the legal criteria for a modification—or if you’re unsure but concerned for your child’s emotional health—a Tampa divorce lawyer can provide clarity, guide you through alternative dispute resolution methods, and, if necessary, represent you in court. By approaching this issue with empathy, open communication, and professional legal advice, you can create a more stable and nurturing environment that respects both the legal framework and your child’s emotional well-being.

At The McKinney Law Group, we provide expert legal services in family law, estate planning, and divorce, with a special focus on high-asset divorce cases. Serving clients in Florida and North Carolina, our experienced attorneys offer tailored solutions to meet your individual needs. Whether you’re looking for a prenuptial agreement in Tampa Bay, need help with estate planning in Asheville, or are navigating a high-asset divorce, we provide the guidance and support you need to make informed decisions and achieve the best possible outcome.

We adopt a client-centered approach, taking the time to understand your goals and developing legal strategies that work for you. With offices in both Florida and North Carolina, we ensure that trusted legal support is easily accessible.

At The McKinney Law Group, we focus extensively on prenuptial agreements, estate planning, and high-asset divorcecases. Our team is dedicated to protecting your assets, guiding you through complex legal challenges, and helping you navigate your legal journey with confidence.

Contact Damien McKinney at 813-428-3400 or email [email protected] to schedule a consultation. Let us help you with the legal guidance you need and deserve.